Volume 15, Issue 1 Spring 2026 You Can’t Budget Your Way Out of Poverty: Rethinking Financial Literacy in Adult Education
Author: Katie Donoviel
Subject Area: ESL/ELL, Financial Literacy
Program Level: COABE Journal
Material Type: Journal
Language: English
License: (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) For license summary click here

Abstract:

This reflection explores how traditional financial literacy instruction in adult English language programs can unintentionally reinforce frustration rather than empowerment. While budgeting lessons are often introduced as practical tools for financial stability, they can expose deeper systemic barriers that make balancing income and expenses impossible for many adult learners. The hidden costs of poverty, such as limited access to affordable healthcare, childcare, transportation, and housing, as well as the financial obligations many immigrants carry, including remittances and repayment of travel loans, are examined. Effective financial literacy instruction must move beyond budgeting to include navigation of systems, resources, and community supports. When educators frame financial literacy as both language and resource literacy, lessons become opportunities for empowerment and advocacy rather than deficit-based exercises. The reflection calls on adult education practitioners to recognize learners’ cultural and familial responsibilities as integral to financial decision-making and to teach financial skills that are relevant, compassionate, and connected to real life.